The game's mystery narrative was praised for its proper motivation for the villain, with the Valentine/Humber romance plot adding an engaging subplot.

Players highlighted the well-developed and realistic in-game characters, such as Bet and Ed, as a standout element.

The overall character interactions and dialogue were described as enjoyable and contributing to the game's charm.

The game's soundtrack was repeatedly cited as the players' absolute favorite of the entire Nancy Drew series, with many commenting on frequently listening to it outside of the game.

While some puzzles were noted as tedious or relying on chance, certain players praised the challenge and satisfaction of solving the more intricate puzzles, such as the treasure hunt-style clues.