The game's simple point-and-click controls allow even young children to easily navigate the environment and interact with objects. Players praise the way these mechanics enhance problem-solving skills as they help Putt-Putt and Rover work together to overcome obstacles.

The game seamlessly incorporates educational elements, such as counting moon crystals to learn math and recognizing music patterns to solve puzzles. These gameplay features teach valuable lessons in a fun and engaging way.

Players highlight the game's ability to reinforce important themes, like the benefits of cooperation and the lasting power of friendship, through the interactive storyline and character interactions.

Reviewers describe the characters, particularly Putt-Putt and Rover, as having unique and well-crafted personalities that they genuinely connect with. The dialogue between the characters is praised for its ability to elicit genuine laughter and emotion.

The game's narrative is lauded for its depth and ability to provoke strong emotional responses, with one player describing it as a "visceral, strong, and heavy experience" that left a lasting impact.

Many players express a deep appreciation for the game's ability to evoke fond memories of their childhood and the Putt-Putt series, underscoring the game's enduring appeal and ability to resonate with long-time fans.

The game's power to forge personal connections and even have a transformative impact on players' lives is evident in reviews, demonstrating its ability to become a cherished part of players' gaming histories.