The game's narrative manages to subvert player expectations by initially leading them to suspect one character, only to surprise them by revealing the true culprit behind the mysterious death of William Gordon

Players can uncover rich historical details about the Gordon family's dark legacy through the extensive collection of letters, journals, and books scattered throughout the game

The game establishes a tangible sense of foreboding and dread through its use of ominous background music, unsettling sound effects (e.g. creaking doors, howling winds), and flickering candles/shadows that create an ever-present air of unease

The puzzles, while challenging, rely on logical thinking and observation rather than obscure or illogical solutions, providing a genuine sense of accomplishment when solved

Progression in the game often requires players to carefully examine their surroundings and piece together clues from conversations, forcing them to stay engaged and attentive

The inability to skip puzzles ensures that gameplay remains meaningful and integral to advancing the story, rather than feeling like optional diversions

While some voice acting is uneven, certain characters deliver their lines with an entertainingly over-the-top campiness that adds to the game's gothic charm

A few supporting characters, such as the mysterious woman who reveals she destroyed an important key, are intriguing in their own right and help deepen the overall mystery

The protagonist, Samuel Gordon, serves as an effective audience surrogate, with his hand-wringing anxiety and persistent questioning driving the player to uncover the truth behind his family's tragic past