The game encourages exploration and experimentation by providing unique, often humorous, responses when combining items from the player's inventory with interactive objects in the environment. For example, one review mentions getting an achievement for trying to feed a Bubsy poster a pet treat, with a hilarious result.

The "Strifes" - combat sequences presented as puzzle-like minigames - are designed to be enjoyable challenges rather than frustrating obstacles. Players cannot fail these sequences, allowing them to focus on the puzzle-solving aspect.

The writing deeply invests players in the characters and their stories, with reviews praising the well-developed personalities and the way players can learn about them by thoroughly examining their homes. One reviewer noted that they became "instantly in love with the characters and the story."

The game's meta-narrative style, which directly addresses the player, resonates with fans of the Homestuck webcomic, enhancing the sense of immersion and connection to the world.

The game's soundtrack is described as memorable and complementary to the experience, with reviews highlighting specific tracks that have remained "stuck in their heads" long after playing.

HIVESWAP: ACT 1 successfully blends the distinctive style and humor of Homestuck with broader '90s nostalgia, appealing to both long-time fans of the webcomic and newcomers to the universe. One reviewer, who was not familiar with Homestuck, noted that the game served as an accessible introduction to the setting.