The game's narrative effectively builds upon the lore and characters established in the previous "Yesterday" game, providing a meaningful continuation of the storyline. Players praise the complexity of the plot, which spans multiple time periods and features a central mystery surrounding the protagonist's immortality.

The story includes well-crafted, morally ambiguous characters, with a surprising and satisfying conclusion that answers key questions while leaving some new ones for players to ponder.

The game's unique twist on the traditional point-and-click adventure formula allows players to closely examine and interact with objects and characters from multiple angles, adding depth to the puzzle-solving experience.

The ability to switch between the two protagonists, John and Pauline, during certain chapters adds variety to the gameplay and provides different perspectives on the unfolding events.

The game's voice acting is consistently praised for its high quality, with convincing and well-delivered performances that enhance the overall narrative experience.