The game's hand-drawn, comic book-inspired environments and character designs effectively capture the dark, gothic tone of the fictional city of Noctropolis. Players reported being immersed in the supernatural, noir-like ambiance.

The MIDI-synthesized musical score complements the game's moody atmosphere, evoking the feel of a gritty action/thriller film.

The game's comic book aesthetic, with its stylized art and panel-based layouts, provides a unique visual experience for players.

The premise of being transported into the world of a discontinued comic book series offers an engaging narrative hook that pulls players into the game's fantastical setting.

While the dialogue features some campy, over-the-top elements, players found the writing to have a self-aware sense of humor that added to the game's B-movie charm.

The game's story, despite some narrative inconsistencies, maintains player interest and motivates them to see the adventure through to its conclusion.

For players who experienced the game during its original 1990s release, Noctropolis elicits a strong sense of nostalgia for the era of classic FMV adventure games.

The inclusion of the original soundtrack and bonus comic book material caters to the game's dedicated fanbase, allowing them to relive the experience with new quality-of-life improvements.

The retro aesthetic and design choices appeal to those who enjoy revisiting the aesthetic and design sensibilities of the 1990s gaming landscape.